Holiday Season Entertaining Made Easy

Click Here to Order Online

All menu items are prepared with local and organic foods whenever possible and always produced in small batches.

Christmas Day, Christmas Eve & Chanukah – Must be placed by December 17th
New Years Eve Orders – Must be placed by December 23rd
Order Pick Up Dates: December 24th & December 31st by 11:30 AM
Our Holiday Menu is available all season long for any occasion, as well as our seasonal menu! For all other orders, we simply require a 72 hour lead time.

Download a copy of our menu

Holidays in the Hamptons
Feel free to call with questions or to place your order by phone 631-267-2411 – or email us We are now centrally located at The Barn, 264 Butter Lane, Bridgehampton, NY


Sugar and Spiced Mixed Nuts Gluten Free $7.95 half pint
Back Deck Smoked Almonds Gluten Free $7.95 half pint
Homemade Potato Chips – Served with Toasted Shallot Dip    serves 15-20 Vegan/GF $69
Bags of AOE Potato Chips – Plain, Parsley and Garlic or Sweet Potato Vegan/GF $9 each
Herbed Cheese Sticks   $36 dozen
Medley of Spiced Marinated Olives Vegan/GF $7.50 half pint
Green Olives and Cream Cheese Stuffed Celery Vegetarian/GF $7.50 dozen
Mini Franks in Puff Pastry with Horseradish Mustard   $14 dozen
Cheeses – An Eye Pleasing Selection of Artisan, Imported and American Cheeses – Garnished with Dried and Fresh Fruit; Our Own Chutney and Crackers   (serves 8-12) Vegetarian $130
Not So Traditional Relish Tray – Our Own Pickled Local and Organic Beets, Onions, Carrots, Cauliflower, Fennel and Green Beans with Marinated Olives   serves 6-10 Vegan/GF $39.50
Antipasto – Italian Delicacies including Prosciutto “Gran Reserve”, Fresh Mozzarella, Roasted Sweet Peppers, Spicy Artisanal Salamis, Marinated Artichoke Hearts, Marinated Pecorino, Housemade Caponata and Cured Olives      Serves 12-18 Gluten Free $153.50
Baked Bucheron en Croute, Armagnac Apricot, Almonds and Crackers  – Serves 10-20   $60
Jumbo Shrimp – All shrimp is steamed in our kitchens – these superior quality white shrimp never touch water – steamed over herbs and chilled on (not in) ice to retain that real shrimpy taste  
– Steamed Peeled Shrimp with Traditional Cocktail Sauce, Remoulade and Lemon Gluten Free $39 dozen
– Cajun Marinated Beer Steamed Shrimp with Lemon Dill Sauce and Lemon Gluten Free $41 dozen
Caviar Board – Art of Eating Brioche, Lemon, Chopped Onion and House Crème Fraiche – Hackleback or Osetra   Market Price
Thinly Sliced Faroe Island Smoked Salmon Platter with Chopped Red Onion, Lemon, Capers, Dill Sauce and Brown Bread – Hand Sliced by an Expert  – This is The Best Tasting Smoked Salmon That Will Ever Pass Your Lips Gluten Free $34  ½ lb.
Lobster Salad   $74 lb.
Organic House Made Ricotta Cheese with Local Honey and Cracked Pepper   $31
Sardinian Rosemary Flatbread – A Thin Whisper Crackling Bread – Perfect to Dip, Top or Just Eat by Itself 3 Sheets   $15

Dips & Spreads

Herb Crostini with 3 Dips (White Miso Hummus – Ricotta, Poppy Seed and Orange – Roasted Carrot, Pine Nuts, Pomegranate and Harrisa Spread) Serves 12-15   $50
Brandade de Morue – A Delicious Baked Salt Cod and Potato Spread – Serves 4-6 Gluten Free $35
Toasted Shallot Dip   $8.50 1/2 Pint


Organic Potato Pancakes – Chive Sour Cream – Apple Sauce   $19 dozen
Goat Cheese, Apricot and Pistachio or Goat Cheese, Grape and Pistachio “Truffles” Gluten Free $35 dozen
Tiny Bonac Clam Pie   $32 dozen
Stone Crab Claws; Mustard Sauce – Shelled for Clean Bite – Medium Sized   $41 half lb.
Roasted Garlic and Goat Cheese Tartlets   $28 dozen
Sausage Bites – Sausage and Mushrooms with a Little Kick in a Flakey Tart Shell   $34 dozen
Wild Mushroom Strudel – 15 piece roll Vegan $33 each
Nueskes Franks in a Blanket; Horseradish Mustard   $14 dozen
Foie Gras, Grape and Prosciutto Roll – 6 pieces per roll Gluten Free $15.95 per roll
Filet of Beef and Crispy Vegetable Rolls with Horseradish Cream Gluten Free $32.75 dozen
Bite Sized Bacon Clafoutis   $23 dozen
Kale, Fennel and Mushroom Galette   $18.50 each
Mini Chicken Pot Pies   $32 dozen


Little Meatballs with Mom’s Tomato “Gravy”   $24.75 dozen
Oysters Rockefeller – Oven Ready Montauk Pearl Oysters on the Half Shell Topped with Spinach and a Delicately Seasoned Crema 12 Oyster Minimum $43 dozen
Classic Thyme Scented Baked Littleneck Clams – Garlic Herb and Roasted Shallot Butter – 12 Clam Minimum   $23dozen
Chilled Seafood Salad with Shrimp, Calamari, Littleneck Clams and Mussels in Lemon Parsley Dressing  – Serves 4-6 Gluten Free $39 lb.
Baked Stuffed Lobster Tail   –  4 portion minimum   $46 dozen


Creamy Woodland Mushroom Soup Vegetarian $14.95 quart
Lobster Bisque   $23 quart
Salad of Winter Greens with Crisp House Smoked Bacon Lardons, Bleu d’ Averge Cheese and Oranges, Fire Roasted Almonds; Apple Cider Vinaigrette – available with no bacon – Gluten Free Small Serves 4-6 $45 Large Serves 8-12 $90
Salad of Arugula and Frisee, Marinated Black-Eyed Peas (For Luck), Maple Syrup Roasted Tomatoes and Feta; Sherry Vinaigrette -Vegetarian/GF Small Serves 4-6 $45 Large Serves 8-12 $90
Peconic Escargot (Locally Raised) with Tomato Leek and Garlic Butter – Served in Shell 24 Snails   $69


Paella – Chicken, Shrimp, Clams, Mussels and Chorizo Cooked with Saffron Rice  (Available without Chorizo)   $80 half pan
Porchetta – Boneless Stuffed Loin of Pork with Apples, Prunes and Armagnac Sauce – Crisp Pork Belly Wrapped Around Pork Loin Scented with Coriander, Fennel, Lemon and Garlic; Salsa Verde  – Serves 10-12   $248
Pepper Crusted Whole Filet of Beef with Onion Crisps; Sauce Madeira Approx. $220 per Filet
Montauk Fluke en Papillote – Roasted Sang Lee Tomatoes, Winter Fennel and Baby Turnips  – 4 person minimum Gluten Free $36 portion
Whole Grilled Salmon – A Whole Boneless Fish, Stuffed with Citrus, Oven-Dried Grapes and Fresh Herbs, Grilled over Maple Wood – Serve at Room Temp. (10 lb. minimum)  – 10 lbs. will feed 35-45 for cocktails and 16-20 people Gluten Free $45.50 lb
Black Pepper Lemon Herb Crusted Roast Organic Chicken; Pan Juices   $29 each
Baked Coffee Orange Glazed Heritage Ham Studded with Cloves – Half or Whole Ham   $12.50 lb.
Classic Beef Bourguignon – Tender Cubes of Beef, Carrots, Cipollini Onions and Woodland Mushrooms in a Rich Burgundy Sauce Half Pan (Serves 8-14) $160 Full Pan (Serves 16-20) $295
Grilled Vegetable Lasagne with Mecox Farms Ricotta – Vegetarian Half Pan $75 Full Pan $135
Grilled Meat Lasagne with House Ricotta Half Pan $90 Full Pan $155
Roast Turkey with Tuscan Bread Dressing and Gravy   $14.95 lb.
Leg of Lamb Pinwheel with Mint, Pinenuts and Roasted Garlic   $29 lb.
Confit of Duck Cassoulet, Beans and Sausage in a Classic Preparation – Serves 4   $175
Macaroni & Cheese Half Pan $105



Leek Scented Roasted Organic Yukon Gold Potatoes with Vidalia Onions –Serves 3-4 Vegan/GF $16.50 quart
Potato Pancakes (Dinner Sized)   6 piece minimum Gluten Free $3.25 each
Braised Red Cabbage and Cherries  – Serves 3-5 Vegan/GF $10.75 pint
Roasted Asparagus with Truffle Butter   – Serves 3-4 Gluten Free $26 quart
Creamed Leaf Spinach – Serves 2-3   $11.25 pint
East End Winter Squashes Roasted with Sweet Onions and Milk Pail Apples  – Serves 2-4 Vegan/GF $11.95 pint
French Lentil, Sweet Potato, Brussel Sprout and Purple Grape; Spinach Microgreens; Balsamic Soy Dressing   $65 half pan
Kale, Delicata Squash, Baby Carrots, Roasted Beets, Pomegranate and Sesame   $60 half pan
Gruyere and Thyme Stacked Potatoes   $75 half pan
Lemongrass Broccoli with Crispy Shallots   $19 quart
Roasted Deep Roots Farm Sweet Potato Wedges with Honey, Chilis and Lime; Yogurt Drizzle   $65 half pan

This & That

Old Fashioned Chicken Pan Gravy   $12.75 quart
Madeira Sauce – Great on Filet Gluten Free $9.50 half pint
White Clam Sauce – Made with Briney Local Clams and Their Juices   $18.50 pint
Horseradish Cream – Great on Beef or Salmon   $6.95 half pint
Lemon Dill Sauce – Compliments Fish, Vegetables and Shrimp Gluten Free $6.95 half pint
Aged Sherry Vinaigrette Vegan/GF $7.95 half pint
Angel Biscuits – A Cross Between a Buttermilk Biscuit and A Parker House Roll   $2.25 each
Whipped Cream   $7 pint


 Beach Plum Raspberry Linzer Cookie  – A Big Star Shaped Cookie    $19 Half Dozen
Tangy Lemon Mousse with Blood Orange Confit and Phyllo Cup – Mousse without Cup is Gluten Free  4 Portion serving $30 each
French Almond Cake  – 12 pieces   $42 each
Sweet Potato Pistachio Tart with Candied Turmeric and Black Pepper Anglaise   $44 each
Chocolate Nut Bark Vegan/GF $28 for 4 oz.
Sweet and Salty Nut Brittle   $22   half lb.
Big Fat Banana Cream Pie with Coconut – Serves 8-10   $49 each
Ellie’s Ricotta Pudding – Whipped Ricotta and Cream with Shaved Valhrona Chocolate and Walnuts  – Serves 3-4 Gluten Free $12.75 pint
Apple Crumble  – Serves 12-16   – can also be made fruit juice sweetened Vegan $48.50 half pan
Chocolate Soufflé Cake (flourless)   Serves 8-12 Gluten Free $39 each
Big Coconut Macaroons   –  6 piece minimum   $2.50 each
Maple, Cinnamon, Almond Cookies Gluten Free $24 dozen
Assorted Handcrafted Cookies – Ask What’s Baking Today   $35 dozen
Chocolate Dipped Cornmeal Biscotti   $38 dozen
Individual Sorbet Ice Cream Cakes in a Jar   $51 half dozen
Chocolate Tiramisu Pie   $62 each
Chocolate Chunk Brownie Bites   $28 dozen
Sea Salt and Brown Butter Rice Krispy Treats  – Two Bites   $27 dozen
Snicker Bar Cake   $62
Bitty Blondie Bites   $26 dozen

“We can’t stop talking about how wonderful everything was – the two of you are truly artists – all of your personal touches and the staff made the day a dream come true.” – Randy & Georgia

“The food, presentation and staff far exceeded my expectations. I can’t tell you how many of our guests have commented about how special everything was.” – Mike & Valerie

How Much Should I Order?
It really all depends on what type of meal you’re attempting to achieve for how many people. If you’re ordering a variety of bites, salads, mains, and sides – use the lower end of the spectrum in the quantity. If you’re only ordering a few items – assume people will take hearty portions of each.

Half pans are usually a sufficient quantity of salad or sides for 6-12 people.
Quarts of soup & sides are good for 2-4 people or dip for 8-10.
For meats, we recommend approximately 8 – 10 oz per person (more if you want leftovers)
Please Note: Art of Eating does not accept credit cards for payment – please have a check or cash available upon pick up.